Jan 6, 2021

Jails and the New Year 2021

 

This is Tinka Jail Radio: Jails in Haryana to get their own radio

·       Jails of Ambala, Panipat and Faridabad to start jail radio

·       5 inmates from Panipat, 6 from Ambala and 10  from Faridabad were chosen radio presentation skill training

·       Trained by prison reformer Dr. Vartika Nanda.

·       One hour long daily programs on current affairs, jail news and songs

New Year has bought some good news for the jails in Haryana. For the first time, these jails will have their own jail radio which has been named as “Tinka Jail Radio”. Haryana has a total of 19 jails, out of which 3 are central jails whereas 16 are district jails. For the time being, jails in Haryana have a total of 20,423 inmates out of which more than 900 are females. Jail radio in the state is set to be started in the Central Jail, Ambala, District Jail, Panipat and District Jail, Faridabad. Auditions were held in the month of December after which 21 inmates from 3 jails were selected for the jail radio. (5 inmates from Panipat jail, 6 inmates from Ambala Jail and 10 inmates from Faridabad jail). These include 5 female inmates from Faridabad jail Inmates were trained by Dr. Vartika Nanda, prison reformer and the Head of Department of Journalism in Lady Shri Ram College, Delhi University.

Selected inmates of these 3 jails were a part of 5 day radio training programme. These inmates are from different age groups and educational backgrounds. The purpose of the training was to prepare inmates to make radio programs along with making them understand about the needs and importance of jail radio.

The closing ceremony of the training programme was held at District Jail, Faridabad with the valedictory address by the Director General of Haryana Prisons Shri K. Selvaraj. Inmates were given feedback and also the certificate.

Radio station will be set up in the jail premises and will be broadcast though speakers set up outside the barracks. People from outside will not be able to connect with this station. It will have programming on legal issues, disease prevention, in-house talent and music. Inmates will also be able to submit requests or questions which will be answered in the next program.

According to Vartika Nanda, “Jails have already starting witnessing a change in prison atmosphere Inmates are busy polishing their talent, they are using the radio lingo and addressing each other as RJs. inmates will be both producers and the consumers. We are making a special model of Tinka Model of Prison Reforms which will be shared with other prisons across the country. Tinka Tinka is working towards becoming a bridge between prisons.”

A list of artists in the jail is being prepared which will decide their participation in the jail radio. Inmates from these 3 prisons have prepared their own intro song and tune. Inmates are searching for new opportunities using the limited resources in prison and are acting as counsellors for each other.

Jail radio was introduced for the first time in 2013 in the Tihar Prison. Dr. Nanda was present during that time to witness this event. Tinka Tinka launched jail radio on 31 July, 2019 in District Jail Agra, which remains as the oldest prison building in India. At the start of this jail radio, 2 inmates- Uday and Tuhina- were trained as RJs. Later, another inmate Rajat Sanjay took charge of the radio. Agra Jail Radio established a female inmate as a radio jockey for the first time.

In the second phase of Tinka Tinka Prison Model, all jails in Haryana will have their own jail radio. The radio name of each jail will be connected to its location like Tinka Jail Radio Ambala, Tinka Jail Radio Faridabad and Tinka Jail Radio Panipat. These inmates have been prepared in such a manner that has probably never been done in any other jail in India.






Dec 22, 2020

Tinka Tinka Prisons: HT City: 22 December, 2020

Tinka Tinka started its formal journey in 2013. From Tihar Prisons to Dasna, Madhya Pradesh and then several jails across the country, Tinka has become my prayer. तिनका रोज बहुत कुछ देखता है, सोखता है। अपनी चुप्पी के बीच हौले कदमों से चल रहा है- तिनका तिनका। Thank you HT City for giving this space, attention and honour. #vartikananda #tinkatinka #prison #jail 

Dec 16, 2020

Will Print Media Survive? Speaker at a national conference on the issues of media


 

Status of Children of Women Prisoners:


Delievred lecture on Status of Children of Women Prisoners: Issues and Concerns, orgnaised by NICFS from 14-16 December, 2020


Tinka Tinka India Awards: 2020: Covid-19 in Jails

Tinka Tinka India Awards- 2020: Honours Jails on Human Rights Day

~17 detainees and prison officers selected this year~

 

· 17 inmates and jail staffers awarded

· Uttar Pradesh received the highest number of awards

· Amitabh Bachchan awarded for Jail Sanitization; one award given post posthumously.

· Theme for this year was Corona in Jail.

· Awards were released by Shri K. Selvaraj (IPS) DG, Haryana Prisons, Shri Ajay Kashyap (IPS) Former DG, Tihar Prisons, Shri Anand Kumar DGP and IG Prisons, UP

· Jury included, Shri Ajay Kashyap (IPS), Shri OP Singh (IPS) and Dr. Vartika Nanda (Founder, Tinka Tinka)

On the eve of Human Rights Day, Tinka Tinka Awards India 2020 has been announced. This is the 6th year of celebration of exclusive awards for inmates and staff. This is the first time that inmates joined live and shared their thoughts in the presence of senior jail officials.

There were 3 categories this year, namely Painting, Special Mention and Prison Administration. 7 inmates have received awards in the Painting category while 6 were chosen for their special contribution to prison life. 4 awards have been given too prison staff which includes one given posthumously. 


Nov 23, 2020

Podcast on Prisons

Exclusive prison radio dedicated to prison reforms

  • Released by Shri Dnyaneshwar Mulay, Member, National Human Rights Commission
  • Conceptualised by prison reformer Vartika Nanda, this is a part of Tinka Tinka series, aiming to bring prisons together
  • Weekly broadcasts featuring insightful stories about prions
  • Broadcasts will be on the website of Tinka Tinka Foundation

Inmates lodged in Central Jail, Bhopal, Model Jail, Chandigarh and Central Jail, Jaipur have one thing in common. They all have contributed in helping the outside world during Covid-19 by making masks and sanitizers. Such ongoing efforts have largely gone unnoticed. With nearly 1400 jails in India, several inmates have done extraordinary work in bringing difference to the jail-life but these are hardly discussed in a public forum. To bring into light such significant contribution of inmates, a podcast exclusively for the incarcerated has been launched. Tinka Tinka Jail News would focus on untold stories of prisons. Created by Vartika Nanda, prison reformer and founder of Tinka Tinka, this series aims to document prison life through audio narratives. It will focus on the special contributions of inmates during Covid-19 for the next few episodes and encourage them to send their nominations for Tinka Tinka India Awards. These national awards are given annually on the occasion of International Human Rights Day to celebrate creativity in jails.

This podcast is released by Shri Dnyaneshwar Mulay, IFS (Retd) Member, National Human Rights Commission and former Secretary, Government of India, Releasing the podcast, Shri Mulay said, “ This is an absolutely novel idea which would certainly address the communication needs of inmates. The concept of involving women inmates in this endeavour is welcoming. One can hope that Tinka Tinka will help in the reformation process in jails.”

The podcast will be sent to the stake holders on a regular basis to initiate the process of change and include valuable suggestions for the improvement of the living conditions of inmates in general and their communication needs in particular. 

Background: Tinka Tinka is an initiative by Dr. Vartika Nanda, a prison reformer, to bring change in the lives of the inmates. Her three books, Tinka Tinka Tihar, Tinka Tinka Dasna and Tinka Tinka Madhya Pradesh depict life in prisons through unique expressions. Her website on prisons, www.tinkatinka.org was released by Shri Kiren Rijiju, MOS, Home while her song, Tinka Tinka Tihar, was released by Lok Sabha Speaker Smt. Sumitra Mahajan. Tinka Tinka is her movement on prison reforms. 

Oct 26, 2020

Trends in Sectional News

 TRENDS IN SECTIONAL NEWS

Disclaimer: The views expressed in this essay are personal and strictly for educational purposes.

Newspapers are weighty in substance and content. They typically contain different types of information catering to diverse audiences with varied interests. An essential element of editing, thus, remains categorically identifying and locating jumble of news content in different sections of the newspaper.
The content analysis of newspapers has shown several trends which can be described as new kinds of application in Print Media.
Maximum number of subjects are now being covered by newspapers. Newspapers are giving information about health, education, science, environment, crime, accident, culture, tourism, literature, information technology, religion, spiritual etc. Maximum number of events are being covered by newspapers. The combination of various elements of design has been so dynamic, that it comes to give a striking resemblance to a TV programme. Supplements of newspaper have become an important and regular part of newspaper. All newspapers are now giving additional pages covering certain areas of daily life. Similarly, newspapers also give weekly magazines covering health, beauty, house decoration, designing, health, food habits and modern lifestyles.
The following are the various types of sections a newspaper lays hold to:
  • General News – This is usually the most important news in both local and abroad. These are usually found on the front page of the paper. The title of the news is printed in big, bold letters called “banner headline”
  • Local and Foreign News Section – Contains news from towns and cities of the nation and abroad.
  • Editorial Page – This section contains articles called editorials. Editorials give views or opinions of the editor or publisher on certain issues or events.
  • Sports Page – This section contains news on events containing sports from in and out of the country. This section also contains well-known people in the sports world.
  • Classified Ads Section – Contains advertisements that fall under the categories like “Help”, “Wanted”, “For Lease / For Sale”, and “Wanted To Buy”.
  • Business and Finance Section – Contains businessmen and people interested in business with information on banking. foreign exchange rates, imports and exports, and prices of prime commodities.
  • Entertainment Section – Contains info about movies, radio, television and other activities for entertainment.
  • Home and Culture Section – Provides info about budgeting, food preparation, house improvement, etc.
  • Society Page – Contains news about important people who are celebrating special events in a particular place
  • Travel and Tourism Section – Contains a guide to travel and directs tourists to a scenic vacation spots and gives information on the activities in these places.
  • Announcements and Obituary Page – Provides info on the activities of different religious sections and also lists people who recently died and the time and place of their burials.

The most important of these remains that of national/regional news with a fixed slot to accommodate this type of news. Most of the space in this category is filled with political issues. Usually, news of national importance is in the inside pages of the newspaper, which comes right after city and regional sections. Then comes the editorial section which contains the editorial of the newspaper along with opinion pieces and columns written by experts, along with editorial cartoons. The Editorial section is typically followed by the business or world page, both of which have been increasing in importance in terms of both readership and content matter in the last two decades. The Sports section, which follows, accommodates sports news and is designated for the last pages of the newspaper.

A New Organisational Style

There are different ways of organization and presentation as far as print media is concerned. The specific organization adopted by a newspaper reflects the personality of the publication. Readers also become accustomed to the organization, and a make-over is rarely done for this reason. It can also be noted that the online versions of these newspapers do not have the breadth and scope of the paper versions.

News stories, features, graphics are certainly being given in TV style of presentation. For example, they give brief story on front page and detail on inner pages. The design of the page is done in such a manner so the advertisement and news text blend with each other. This is given just to make audience view the advertising and to avoid their negligence towards advertising materials. The number and space of advertisement has certainly increased. Nature of competition among newspapers can also be a reason for the new trend in presentation. This is evident from the practice where every newspaper claims to give the most exclusive news. There are several occasions in which newspapers like to bring up their achievements in terms of old reportage that acted as a catalyst for administrative action in the past. These stories are distinguished by others by use of special logo and symbolic graphics.

Sectional Trends

Strong readership is a key aspect of print media industry. A high proportion of this readership can be achieved by laying focus on the best coverage of regional and local issues. In most newspapers, city and regional news sections come right after the front page, explaining how important they are for both the newspaper industry and the readers wishing to read about issues most immediate to them first. Unlike sections containing national news which are heavily dependent on news agencies and outsourcing of information, news in regional/local sections is reliant entirely on local reporters, requiring an efficient regional bureau as the backbone of a newspaper house.  Newspapers are covering local issues much more than before. Earlier the local coverage was given in two or three pages. Now news of other districts is in a very small quantity. This trend is seen in all newspapers ranging from Dainik Jagran, Hindustan, Amar Ujala, and Rashtriya Sahara newspapers, all of which are giving eight to nine pages to local or city news. Some critics comment that this trend deprives people from laying equal emphasis to news of national and/or global importance, but this can be balanced by a substantial coverage of the latter categories in tandem with the subject matter raised in local and regional news sections.

Crime and accident stories are given high priority. The Economic page covers mainly investment, loan, insurance, purchase. Coverage of commonplace issues with a general tonality to suit all regions of the country has also been accepted as a mode to gain wider traction.

Cultural reporting has acquired a very prominent place in newspapers. All newspapers are not only giving text material but also supplementing it with visual representation. In fact, photojournalism has become a common feature for the best coverage of cultural issues. As new cultures emerge and as citizens become active participants in the media industry, cultural activities and events have become one very important area of reporting. The content, headlines, photographs, articles, features, all have an orientation towards increasing consumerism, modern social values, and culture.

Newspapers are now giving information about all those activities which are closely associated with daily lives of common people and society, for example, the information about transport, market, various commodities. Similarly, people's problems associated with water, electricity, transport are being highlighted. It is really a very positive approach of the newspapers. They are fulfilling the need of information of various sections of people. Print Media has started to give maximum coverage to those subjects which are useful in one or other way to daily lives of common people.

The follows-up of various events have further increased. A newspaper tries its best to give a meaningful coverage of an event. The follow up of news is given more in Crime and Political subjects. The news series are more prevalent in those events which are of public importance. Many a times, newspapers even tend to launch campaigns around particular areas of interest.

Newspapers are giving active support to various academic activities which are related to youth and unemployed people. This benefits a newspaper doubly- it clears passage for the newspaper to gain positive publicity, and it also enables it to connect to the crucial sections of the population directly and widen its base. There are many occasions when the newspapers take the opinion of youth on important issues. Oftentimes, youth fair, discussion and other programmes, beyond newspaper columns is also organised by the publishing house.

Another area is the history and background of news events, which has become almost a vital element in presentation of the most comprehensive and holistic news information to people, helped by the vast availability of academic material in this regard. Special contexts such as a chronological analysis of an event is presented on specific occasions, including essential court judgements. This kind of information was presented in early newspapers; however, it has considerably increased in frequency in recent times. Infographics for events of wide public interest, such as in the outbreak of major diseases, is also essentially presented for the benefit of a large section of readers.

Another emergent trend has been that newspapers have come to depict themselves as educators, motivators and advisers, something which is unique to the present generation of print media. For instance, political coverage often includes the hows and whys of voting, technological coverage tends to employ a tone of guidance about the market, while educational news may include specific columns with experts resolving general public queries on request.

Despite these, there are some areas which are least covered by newspapers. They include information about government programmes, and development issues. Newspapers hardly cover such subjects, as per latest trends, since it is believed they do not get as much acquired readership as other areas of interest and remain limited to a very small section of affected people. However, this negative trend is seen to be neutralised as newspapers are starting to realise the essentiality of citizen journalism, and some noticeable space is being granted to areas pertinent to people.  

The onset of globalisation has also led to greater traction to news of global importance. Along the years it has been found that the economic power of countries plays a particularly crucial role in their news prominence as well as the presence of international news agencies. Thus, the US has been found to be very prominent in news mentions around the world (18%), followed by China, Western European and Middle Eastern countries (about 3-5% each).

 Sectional Readership

Among the readers of Sunday newspapers, it was found that the mean number of sections regularly read is 6.2, while the median number of sections regularly read is 4. About 16% of the readers regularly read 10 or more sections.

The most popular newspaper section is 'Local/domestic/national news' (read by 65% of the readers), followed by 'Sports' (read by 59%). The least popular sections are 'Home & Decoration' (read by 13%) and 'Letters from the Readers' (read by 12%). Newspaper sections do not arise in a vacuum, because they are there in response to consumer demands and competitive pressure. For example, there would not be a Computer section anywhere twenty years ago.Publics around the globe consume all types of news, but they are most interested in news that’s close to home. Among the four key news topics asked about, global medians of at least three-quarters say they follow news about their country (86%) or city and town (78%) closely, compared with fewer than six-in-ten who say the same when it comes to news about other countries generally (57%) and the U.S. specifically (48%).

Interest in international news varies by geographic region. Europeans are most likely to say they follow international news closely (median of 65%), while people in Latin America express the lowest level of interest in this type of news (35%). There is little variation, on the other hand, in the percentage that follows international news very closely; in all countries surveyed, no more than three-in-ten say they follow international news very closely.

There has also been a considerable segue into market-orient information in the middle of general news information. Advertisers have begun to use newspaper readers as potential consumers and tend to guide them in purchasing and marketing.

The fact that the readers seldom read all the sections have ramifications for advertisers. If different types of readers read different sections, then the sectional placement of an ad becomes an important issue. Some situations are clear: a car dealer probably wants to be in the Automobile section, a computer store wants to be in the Computer section, a travel agent wants to be in the Travel section, etc.

In other situations, the choices are less obvious. For example, think about an airline. The Travel section is one obvious place. But are there other opportunities? What about Business section for the business traveller who makes frequent trips, for example? Or think about a beverage producer. The Sports section, the Youth section and the Food section all have their special appeals.

This last thought leads us to contemplate the possibility that newspaper readers can be segmented based on their sectional readership. That is, certain readers read certain sections.

Trends in sectional news in print media are similar to most other trends in the field. It is obvious that readership patterns and market demands would continue to shape organisational patterns of a newspaper. New sections are bound to arise, and several others might be compelled to limitation.

 REFERENCES

By: Samridhi Chugh, BA (Hons) Journalism, Lady Shri Ram College, Batch of 2022

Tinka Tinka Jail News: The Jail Newsletter

Periodicity: Quarterly

Editor: Dr. Vartika Nanda
Launching Year: 2020
Copyright: Tinka Tinka Foundation

 Tinka Tinka Jail Newsletter is a new feature introduced by Tinka Tinka Fondation. It is a quarterly edition that aims to connect the prisons across India besides bridging the gap between prisons and the society. 
The first issue of the Tinka Tinka Jail News is dedicated to Tinka Tinka Awards 2019. These awards are another initiative of the Tinka Tinka Foundation which are given every year on 10th December, Human Rights Day. In 2019, these awards were released by esteemed guests- Anand Kumar, Director General of Police, Uttar Pradesh and IG, Prisons, Sulkhan Singh, Former Director General of Police, Uttar Pradesh and Vartika Nanda, Founder of Tinka Tinka Foundation.
Awards for 2019 were given to 21 inmates and 8 prison administrators. Tinka Tinka India Awards awards are given exclusively to inmates and jail staff for honouring their creative pursuits and exemplary contribution to the prison atmosphere.  This newsletter is designed by Anurag Kshirsagar, a budding graphic designer from Mumbai.  The first newsletter will be released on the occasion of Dussehra.  
The next issue of the newsletter will be centred on the ongoing COVID-19 epidemic. It will include stories of inmates who have contributed positively to the outside world by making masks and sanitizers for them.
The newsletter will also feature some handwritten letters of inmates.  

Sep 22, 2020

प्रिंस से रिया तक मीडिया से एक तिनका उम्मीद


 

प्रिंस से रिया तक मीडिया से एक तिनका उम्मीद

डॉ. वर्तिका नन्दा

1994 से लेकर अब तक अपराध पत्रकारिता से ताल्लुक रहा। 1994 में जब जी टीवी  की शुरुआत हुई, यही वह समय था जब सुशील शर्मा का तंदूर कांड हुआ। सुशील शर्मा कई दिनों तक फरार रहा। आखिरकार वह पुलिस की गिरफ्त में आया और तिहाड़ में आजीवन कारावास पर रहने के बाद हाल में रिहा हुआ। अपराध की रिपोर्टिंग के असर की यह पहली मिसाल थी जिसकी मैं साक्षी बनी। जे 27 साउथ एक्स पार्ट 1, नई दिल्ली के रिहाइशी इलाके में बने फ्लैटनुमा दफ्तर में इस खबर के पहले प्रसारण के बाद सुशील शर्मा के पकड़े जाने तक दफ्तर में फोन की कई घंटियां बजीं। दर्शक चाहते थे कि अपनी पत्नी नैना को गोली मार कर टुकड़ों में काट कर तंदूर में डाल कर जला देने वाले सुशील को कड़ी सजा जरूर मिले। मिली भी।

बाद में एनडीटीवी के क्राइम बीट की प्रमुख के तौर पर अपराध के अलग- अलग रंगों को करीब से देखा। फिर उसके बाद तिनका तिनका की शुरुआत हुई जिसके जरिए जेल की जिंदगी से अपराध को समझने की कोशिश की।  इस लिहाज से अपराध की कई परतों को पत्रकार और अकादमिक के तौर पर नजदीकी से देखा और महसूस किया। पुलिस की तफ्तीश और जेल सुधार के तौर पर जेल के अंदर किस तरह से अपराधी या फिर आरोपी एक दूसरी यात्रा तरह करते हैं, उसे देखा। 

इस बीच टीवी रिपोर्टिंग को भी गौर से समझने की कोशिश की। हाल में रिया और कंगना की रिपोर्टिंग ने इस बात पर ध्यान दिलाया कि शायद अब इस मुद्दे पर लिखना ज़रूरी है और इसलिए यह आलेख।

बात टीवी की उस खबर से शुरू करनी चाहिए जहां एक टेलीविजन चैनल ब्रेकिंग न्यूज की पट्टी के साथ यह बताता है कि रिया जेल में आने के बाद 11 बजे तक चहलकदमी करती रही और 2:30 बजे तक बिस्तर पर बैठी रही। उसे दाल, रोटी और एक सब्जी दी गई। सुबह उसने मुंह धोया और फिर वो अपने बिस्तर पर बैठ गई। टीवी चैनलों ने यह भी बताया कि रिया के बैरक में पंखा नहीं है, एक चटाई है, सराहना नहीं है वगैरह तो लगा जैसे यह सब किसी जेल में पहली बार होने जा रहा हो। जिन्होंने जेल को कभी नहीं देखा, उनके लिए यह बात एक खबर हो सकती है और इसलिए भी कि ऐसी बताई बातों की पुष्टि करने वाला कभी कोई नहीं होता।

अपराध पत्रकारिता की रिपोर्टिंग में इसे पत्रकारिता तो नहीं कहा जा सकता है। रिया के मामले से पहले भी और अब भी दर्शकों को अक्सर जो परोसा जाता है, वह रिपोर्टिंग कम और मनोहर कहानियों का टीवी संस्करण ज्यादा दिखता है। यह कहानी भी उसी की एक कड़ी है।

एक ज़रूरी बात यह है कि जेल की कहानियां बताते समय कल्पनाओं का सहारा लेना भारतीय टीवी पत्रकारों की एक पुरानी आदत रही है। वे इस बात से अच्छी तरह वाकिफ हैं कि जेलें आमतौर पर सामने आकर न तो ऐसी बेतुकी कहानियों पर कोई हामी भरेंगी और न ही इनकार करेंगी क्योंकि जेलों को इस बात से कोई फर्क नहीं पड़ता कि पत्रकार जेल के बाहर क्या कह रहा है। जेल अधिकारी बखूबी जानते हैं कि जिन पत्रकारों ने जेल को कभी देखा तक नहीं, उनके पास कल्पना ही इकलौता सहारा है औऱ दर्शकों के पास अधकचरी खबर देने वाले पत्रकारों का सहारा। दूसरी बात यह भी है कि कुछ बातें स्वाभाविक हैं जिन्हें लिखने या बोलने का कोई औचित्य है ही नहीं। जो जेल में गया है, उसे स्वाभाविक तौर पर शुरुआती दिनों में नींद नहीं आएगी, वह खाना नहीं खाएगा और बेचैन रहेगा। इसमें ब्रेकिंग न्यूज जैसी कोई बात है ही नहीं।

इसलिए रिया का भी जेल में रात में चहलकदमी करना या 2:30 बजे तक बैठे रहना कोई बड़ी बात नहीं है। इसका खंडन करने कोई सामने आएगा नहीं और इसलिए इस तरह की खबर को बार-बार बताते रहने से टीवी चैनल का फायदा यह होता है कि वो उत्सुक जनता को कुछ ऐसा सौंपने में कामयाब होता है जो उसके लिए रोचक या दिलचस्प हो सकता है, यह समझे बिना कि टीवी न्यूज मनोरंजन की श्रेणी में जरूर आने लगा है लेकिन जेलें मनोरंजन का सामान कतई नहीं हैं। जेल एक गंभीर जगह है और उसकी अपनी अंतहीन पेचीदगियां हैं। उन पर हंसा नहीं जा सकता।

अपराध  रिपोर्टिंग की अपनी एक प़ृष्ठभूमि के बाद यह बात कह सकती हूं कि अपराध की रिपोर्टिंग के जिस नये चेहरे को अब देख रही हूं, उसे अपराध पत्रकारिता मानना असान नही लगता। दूसरी छवि उस पोस्टमैन की है जो कंगना के घर पर डाक लेकर आया था । वो बार-बार जोर देकर यह कह रहा था कि वह महज़ एक पोस्टमैन है। उसका इस दफ्तर को तोड़ने से कोई ताल्लुक नहीं है ,लेकिन पत्रकार अपने रटे-रटाये सवाल को पूछ- पूछ कर शोर मचाते रहे और उस शोर के ज़रिए पत्रकारिता की छवियों का मज़ाक उठाते रहे।

अंदाजे की यह पत्रकारिता को ऐसे मौके किसी अवसर से कम नहीं लगते। अब सवाल यह उठता है कि क्या पत्रकारिता की यह स्थिति अचानक आई है। ऐसा नहीं है। प्रिंस के गढ़्ढे में गिरने से लेकर 2007 में स्कूल टीचर उमा खुराना पर हुए गलत स्टिंग तक मीडिया ने कई बार अपनी ताकत का नाजायज फायदा उठाया है और फिर न तो पलट कर देखा और न ही कभी माफी मांगी। बाद में भी कई प्रिंस गढ्ढे में गिरते रहे और उमा खुराना अपने पर हुए उस मानसिक और शारीरिक हमले से आज भी उबर नहीं पाई हैं। मीडिया ने इस बात की परवाह नहीं की कि एक गलत खबर कैसे किसी परिवार की आने वाले कई नस्लों को तबाह कर सकती है। परवाह टीआरपी की हुई और उसके जरिए बरसने वाले रुपए की। लेकिन ज्यादातर लोग कसमें खाते हैं कि वे इन चैनलोकं को देखते ही नहीं। और अगर इस पत्रकारिता को लोग नकारते है तो फिर इन चैनलों को देखता कोंन है। जाहिर है कि या तो इन्हें देखने वाले झूठ कहते हैं या फिर टीआरपी जारी करने वाले या शायद यह कि झूठ बराबरी का है और सच कहीं बीच में सर पर हाथ रखे खड़ा हुआ है।

सुशांत मामले का सच जब सामने आएगा, तब आएगा लेकिन यह बात तो है कि अब तक परोसी गई सभी थियोरीज तो सच साबित होंगी नहीं। कुछ अधूरा और कुछ गलत भी साबित होगा। तब रिया और कंगना- दोनों में से ही जिसके साथ भी सच होगा, दूसरे की इज्जत के साथ जो खिलवाड़ हुआ, उसका खामियाजा कौन भरेगा। जल्दबाजी में की जाने वाली खऱगोशी अपराध रिपोर्टिंग का सबसे कड़वा सच यही है कि न्यूज रूम की अवैध अदालतें खुद ही जज बनती हैं लेकिन जब उनके फैसले गलत साबित होते हैं तो न तो उन्हें कोई सजा होती है, न कोई धारा लगती है। इस पूरे तमाशे में ताली पीटती जनता और आंखे मूंदे बैठी एनबीए की स्थिति देखकर यह समझना मुश्किल लगता है कि मीडिया के पाठ्यक्रम में अब किस पत्रकारिता को पढ़ाया जाए-वह जो बिकती है या वह जो टिकती है। पढ़ने वाले बिकने वाली पत्रकारिता पढ़ने को आतुर होने लगे है और इंडस्ट्री भी वैसा ही अधपका पैकेज पाने को। मीडिया की पढ़ाई और न्यूजरूम के इस फासले के बीच पत्रकारिता की एक धुंधली रेखा कहीं मौजूद है। बस, उसे ढूंढना टेढ़ी खीर है।


( डॉ. वर्तिका नन्दा मीडिया विश्लेषक और जेल सुधारक हैं। देश की जेलों पर तिनका तिनका की संस्थापक। उन्हें देश के राष्ट्रपति से स्त्री शक्ति सम्मान मिला है। )

(19 सितंबर को राष्ट्रीय सहारा के हस्तक्षेप में प्रकाशित )

email: tinkatinkaorg@gmail.com